Equality : An Excuse
Hi guys!
Welcome to my fourth blog. Hopefully you all are safe and healthy during this
pandemic and after the deadly cyclone. This year is kinda turning out to be one
whole chapter of History with all kinds of incidents happening across the
globe. Recently, the brutal murder of a Black person named ‘George Floyd’ in Minnesota,
United States of America by a white Minneapolis police officer named ‘Derek
Chauvin’ has rightly gained massive criticism, rage from all around the world
and protests in the States. Regarding that a hashtag attached with online
petitions and fundings for stopping Racial discrimination has been trending. In
response to celebrities taking a stance in support of the protests and using
this tag, some people have come up with messages of “All lives matter”. In
today’s blog I’ll be writing about that and how the title is valid for
oppressors…
Firstly, let’s dive
into the actual incident and how it happened.
It began with a report of a fake $20 bill.
A report was made on the evening of 25 May, when Mr Floyd
bought a pack of cigarettes from Cup Foods, a grocery store. Believing the $20 bill
he used to be counterfeit, a store employee reported it to police. According to
the shop owner Mike Abumayyaleh, Floyd was a regular at Cup Foods, a friendly
face, a pleasant customer who never caused any trouble. But Mr Abumayyaleh was
not at work on that day of the incident. In reporting the suspicious bill, his
teenage employee was just following protocol.
The employee called at
911 at 20:01 and narrated the incident to the operator and also said “he
(Floyd) doesn’t want to do that” on demanding the pack of cigarettes back. According
to the employee, Floyd appeared “drunk” and “not in control of himself”.
Shortly after the call, at around 20:08, two police officers arrived. Mr Floyd
was sitting with two other people in a car parked around the corner.
After
approaching the car, one of the officers, Thomas Lane, pulled out his gun and
ordered Mr Floyd to show his hands. In an account of the incident,
prosecutors do not explain why Mr Lane thought it necessary to draw his gun. Mr
Lane, prosecutors said, "put his hands-on Mr Floyd, and pulled him out of
the car". Then Mr Floyd "actively resisted being handcuffed".
It
was when officers tried to put Mr Floyd in their squad car that a struggle
ensued. At about 20:14, Mr Floyd "stiffened up, fell to the ground, and
told the officers he was claustrophobic", according to the report. Mr
Chauvin arrived at the scene. He and other officers were involved in a further
attempt to put Mr Floyd in the police car.
During
this attempt, at 20:19, Mr Chauvin pulled Mr Floyd away from the passenger
side, causing him to fall to the ground, the report said. He lay there, face
down, still in handcuffs. That's when witnesses started to film Mr Floyd, who
appeared to be in a distressed state. These moments, captured on multiple
mobile phones and shared widely on social media, would prove to be Mr Floyd's
last.
Mr
Floyd was restrained by officers, while Mr Chauvin placed his left knee between
his head and neck. "I can't breathe," Mr Floyd said repeatedly,
pleading for his mother and begging "please, please, please". For
eight minutes and 46 seconds, Mr Chauvin kept his knee on Mr Floyd's neck, the
prosecutors' report says.
About
six minutes into that period, Mr Floyd became non-responsive. In videos of the
incident, this was when Mr Floyd fell silent, as bystanders urged the officers
to check his pulse. One of the other officers, JA Kueng, did just that,
checking Mr Floyd's right wrist, but "couldn't find one". Yet the
other officers did not move. At 20:27, Mr Chauvin removed his knee from Mr
Floyd's neck. Motionless, Mr Floyd was rolled on to a gurney and taken to the
Hennepin County Medical Centre in an ambulance.
He
was pronounced dead about an hour later.
Since
then, social media has been flooded with videos and images in support of George
Floyd, in demand of justice against Racism and legalized terrorism present in
the system of the country. The four officers were fired from the Police
department the following day and protests enfolded on streets across America
and more prominently in Floyd’s Hometown Houston, Texas. The protests escalated
as this time people couldn’t stand with the cruelty of the murder.
Drawing
attention from all around the globe, the protests gained momentum and the
brainlessness and heartlessness of the ‘Honourable’ POTUS on calling upon
National Guard to stop the protests infuriated the citizens more. He even went
to the extent of labelling “ANTIFA” as a terrorist group which is not even an
organisation but an umbrella term for people against neo-Nazis and White
Supremacists. During the protests, various violent actions and even murder carried
upon by the Police on Black people at places of peaceful protests surfaced over
the web, which weren’t addressed by the authorities. This drew more agitation
and as of 2nd June, 50 states of USA were protesting against the
practise of Systemic Racism and Trump had declared war over its own citizens
and ordered the military forces to take action.
Now
you might ask that why did this incident trigger such massive outrage
compelling US citizens to take to the streets in a dangerous pandemic. This
incident wasn’t just about Floyd. The rallying point about the “Black Lives
Matter” movement has been about the systematic racist attacks towards ethnic
minorities and the violence and even death of African-Americans from civilians
and Police around the country without any accountability. And there have been
many similar protests in the years before. In fact, the current protests look a
lot like the 2014 BLM movement after Eric Garner, another Black man, had been
choked to death by a white New York City Police officer.
Some
US reports have put out researchers’ data on police violence and CNBC put out
one such report by a group called ‘Mapping Police Violence’ and that data shows
in 2019 that more than 1000 people were killed by the police and black people
accounted for 24% of those killed in spite of making up only 13% of the
population. And there is no accountability. As per the reports, police have
almost never been charged for excessive force violations. Between 2013 and
2019, 99% of those killings resulted in no charges at all.
On
various posts or videos or photos which are being shared on social media being
tagged with “Black Lives Matter” are getting replies like “All lives matter” of
which some are in good spirit while some are not. In whichever context people
are using this, it is wrong. If you are saying ‘All lives matter’ then stop
saying it because no one said they don’t. Of course, all lives do matter. That’s,
without a doubt, a true statement.
As Taylor
Washington, an author and journalist, says, “the purpose of the Black
Lives Matter (BLM) movement isn’t to exclude, but to emphasize the lack of
action and attention brought to the systematic racism and violence black people
are facing. In no way is the movement meant to take away from the importance of human
life of any other race, sexuality, ethnicity, age or gender...”
And
this is not just the case with the ‘Black Lives Matter’ movement. Be it any
movement for basic human rights for a certain community, or sex, or group of
people, there are people who use the subject of equality to use it as a blanket to
cover up the struggle faced by those people who are protesting.
Remind
me the last time a white man was killed by a black man for driving, jogging,
sleeping, yelling, baby-sitting, selling CDs, selling cigarettes, opening the
door, walking at night, wearing a hoodie at night, holding a toy gun, lying on
the ground, being homeless, holding a cell-phone, exercising horses, having a
bottle of pills, shopping at Walmart, eating
ice-cream in their own house or shopping.
These
are the reasons for which Black Men have been killed in America. Yes, it’s
fucked up at so many levels. That’s why it is not about you, it’s about THEM.
Remind
me the last time a man was sexually harassed just for walking in his shorts and
tees at night. Remind me the last time a Hindu Brahmin was held at gunpoint by
the police and was made to sing the National Anthem by the police.
The
tags of ‘All Lives Matter’ or ‘All genders are equal’ or ‘All religions are
equal in this country’ are utopian dreams which the society uses to avoid acknowledging
the struggles of unprivileged people. The purpose of these movements isn’t to
exclude but to fight against the systemic discrimination faced by these
communities for all these years.
By
coming back at someone saying “Black lives matter” with “All lives matter,”
you’re silencing black people. This is not to exclude the importance of other
lives, but to focus on the prevalence of black lives being taken by people who
are supposed to protect them. If you hear someone say this in response to Black
Lives Matter, remind them that the All Lives Matter movement is not as harmless
as they may think. It has been used as a tool to invalidate what the black
community has experienced and the fears and problems they have.
Not
once during this global pandemic did the hashtag “All Lives Matter” trend,
instead we had different variations of us “all being together.” But as
soon as the black community brought up the BLM movement, “All Lives Matter”
started trending.
Equality,
in this case, is just being used as an excuse for cutting voices out and
oppression.
Now,
let’s just switch up the scene a little bit.
The
online support has been there from all around the world including India which
has had its own past of incidents comprising of racial hate, bigotry and police
violence.
Supportive
messages such as a black screen in support of “#BlackoutTuesday” and tweets with
“#BLM” have been all around the social media. We have been supportive to anti-racist
policies in the States whereas our own house has been crumbling down.
Cases
of racism, police violence, discrimination aren’t a new thing which happen in
India but it would certainly be a new thing when we all can voice against them
collectively as it has been the case in the States. The institution of Arrange Marriage
has a block of racism in its base. Flashback to Bhuvan Bam’s video regarding matrimonial
ads with “preferable skin colour for bride/groom”, this thing hasn’t really
stopped yet and neither gained much attention because of our ignorance. Incidents
like domestic violence, killing, mental and physical torture on darker skinned wives
isn’t a thing which escapes from the coverage of our media. A panel of politicians,
actors, news-readers, common people condemn it. Then there’s an ad-break.
I
shall not get into the fairness cream endorsement by superstars and etc.
bullshit. That has already been talked about in a while and the discussion is pointless.
No matter how we talk more the issue doesn’t end until we the people stop
buying such products.
What is
more pathetic is the selective outrage from both celebrities and the common
masses regarding issues in the west just for good PR. Very few celebrities in the
industry have the audacity to voice out their opinions regarding Police
Brutality and issues of communalism in our Country and even when they speak
they face outrage from people like “anti-nationals”, “supporting
left-propaganda” or even death threats from extremists.
Remember
“Goli Maaron Saalon ko!”? Instances of people supporting this statement and
supporting “#BLM” have been recorded over the last week as well. Hypocrisy isn’t
a thing limited to people belonging to the glamour industry or field of politics.
Police beating up Muslim youth, University students (even by breaking into
their libraries), minorities and people belonging to the lower economic block
has been often supported by many in our country and most celebrities have just
turned a blind eye towards those issues for playing it safe.
The
idea of hostile police treatment isn’t even very clear to much of our middle-class
society than that of a poor or minority citizen. Thus, they see no reason to
come out on streets and even if they did like the poor- as we saw during the
mass migration from the cities to the villages- they would be beaten up. Media as well, has been critical of the incidents of racism in US but when it
comes to people protesting in our own country, no one hesitates for once before
calling them out as anti-nationals, as we saw during the anti-CAA protests.
Things
like these should shake up all of us, even if we may not have personally faced
it. These are things about our system that have to change and only public
opinion, expressed jointly and forcefully, can do that. Because, “If not us,
then who?”
Otherwise,
the knee will be on your neck and you will choke to, “I can’t breathe”.
Please
share your opinions in the comments and share the blog if you liked it. Thanks
for reading. Stay Safe : )
Written with a lot of insight.
ReplyDeleteYes #all lives matter is an excuse to turn attention away from the issue at hand
Very insightful and definitely should be read by all. A very unique angle brought in, something which the so-called "privileged class" has always brought in as an alternative viewpoint that sounds politically correct but on a deeper analysis it reveals as a step to override the primary cause of inequality. So it's highly appreciable that you actually came up with this perspective that provides dynamism to any revolutionising narrative. Keep going :)
ReplyDeleteThanks .
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe worst part is these protests prevail only after we lose some one, till then we all are sleeping on a death bed.
ReplyDeleteUnprivelaged lives do matters...
Exactly...we wait until the extreme has happened...things need to change real hard
Delete